Skip to content

Baton Rouge little one killer claims mental incapacity | courts

For the previous three years, specialists have labored to find out if Frank Ford Cosey, a person convicted of one in all East Baton Rouge Parish’s most brutal murders, has the psychological capability to be put to demise for his crime.

An off-and-on courtroom battle designed to find out if he has an mental incapacity reconvened Monday morning contained in the nineteenth Judicial District Courthouse in downtown Baton Rouge. The so-called Atkins listening to is slated to proceed till Thursday and officers anticipate they may lastly end all of the testimony this week.

Cosey, now 62, raped 12-year-old Delky Nelson and slashed her throat inside her house in July 1990. He left the kid bare and spread-eagled in the main bedroom, on show for her mom to find her lifeless physique.

Jurors convicted him in September 1996 and voted unanimously for the demise penalty. Greater than 25 years of authorized wrangling within the case since then has delayed Cosey’s execution.

The Louisiana Supreme Courtroom reaffirmed his conviction and demise sentence in 2000 and the US Supreme Courtroom denied a evaluate of his case in 2001.

Cosey’s authorized workforce is now making an attempt to persuade a decide that the convicted killer is ineligible for the demise chamber as a result of he has his a diminished psychological capability.

It is unlawful to place intellectually disabled convicts to demise. The US Supreme Courtroom deems such executions merciless and strange punishment and dominated it violates the Eighth Modification.

The evidentiary listening to dates again to Could 2019 when Cosey’s attorneys started placing psychologists who’ve evaluated him on the stand. Since then, the listening to has languished, with rounds of testimony going down sporadically just for the case to be postponed a number of months. The final spherical of testimony befell over a five-day span in July.

Cosey’s attorneys known as 5 psychological consultants to testify earlier than resting their case in November. They supplied proof that included summaries of their psychological assessments, tips for forensic psychiatry and Cosey’s college data from highschool.

On Monday, attorneys for the Lawyer Common’s workplace continued presenting their case. Tennessee forensic neuropsychological advisor Jill Hayes testified for hours. She was employed by the state and interviewed Cosey for over six hours in September 2017.

Hayes mentioned she discovered indicators of a studying dysfunction that impacts Cosey’s studying and written expression.

“Further testing and data is required to substantiate to the extent that he has this dysfunction, however it will not represent an mental incapacity,” she testified.

Hayes went on to say that medicine and alcohol abuse have considerably impaired academic, social, and occupational functioning, however “at no level in his life has Mr. Cosey had vital deficits in mental functioning.”

The mental disabilities declare is a part of a petition for post-conviction reduction that Cosey initially filed in 2001 with none allegations of authorized misconduct throughout his trial or appeals. State Supreme Courtroom Justice Scott Crichton wrote in a June 2016 ruling that it was a strategic maneuver of Cosey’s to make use of his paltry utility of him as a placeholder till it obtained the eye of attorneys 11 years later. The authorized workforce beefed up his bare-bones petition in 2015 by citing trial court docket rulings and arguing that Cosey suffered due course of violations, speedy-trial rights violations and ineffective counsel amongst different allegations of authorized misconduct.

Nineteenth JDC Chief Decide Donald Johnson, who’s presiding over the case, denied lots of these motions in 2015. He did aspect with Cosey’s declare that he deserves a listening to to resolve his mental skills.

The Louisiana Supreme Courtroom, in a 4-3 determination in June 2016, opted to permit the evidentiary listening to to maneuver ahead.

Cosey sat within the courtroom Monday subsequent to his attorneys Ankjen Ingraham, Matilde Carbin and Charlotte Faciane.

Cosey was on parole when he raped and killed Delky Nelson on July 6, 1990. The Baton Rouge woman lived throughout the road from him on El Scott Avenue. In keeping with trial testimony, he beat the woman earlier than killing her and stomped on her face so exhausting that the final two letters of the phrase “Reebok” had been stamped on her left cheek.

Cosey’s fingerprints and DNA proof left on the scene led investigators to him. His trial attorneys unsuccessfully argued that one other neighbor of the sufferer’s household was the actual killer.

The listening to is anticipated to reconvene at 8 am Tuesday in Johnson’s courtroom (8B) on the nineteenth Judicial Courthouse, 300 North Blvd.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *