Skip to content

Fairfax Co. colleges, Virginia training officers hit with class motion swimsuit over incapacity hearings

Fairfax County Public Faculties and the Virginia Division of Training have been hit with a federal class-action lawsuit claiming households of disabled youngsters who problem colleges’ choices about specialised training plans do not get a good shake.

Fairfax County Public Faculties and the Virginia Division of Training have been hit with a federal class-action lawsuit claiming households of disabled youngsters who problem colleges’ choices about specialised training plans do not get a good shake.

The lawsuit, filed by Trevor and Vivian Chaplick, the dad and mom of a disabled baby, names as defendants Fairfax County College Board; Michelle Reid, superintendent of the varsity system; the Virginia Division of Training and Jillian Balow, superintendent of public instruction at VDOE.

The swimsuit was filed Wednesday within the Japanese District of Virginia.

The federal People with Disabilities Training Act ensures a free applicable public training to disabled youngsters, and in addition offers dad and mom the suitable to problem colleges’ choices about training offered to their youngsters in a due course of listening to earlier than an neutral listening to officer.

However the lawsuit says households in Northern Virginia who problem colleges’ choices face a “near-insurmountable hurdle” in getting a good listening to, as a result of the state’s “fastidiously curated system of crony listening to officers” are biased towards colleges.

The lawsuit contains beforehand unreported knowledge displaying that oldsters in Northern Virginia who search a listening to difficult a college’s resolution on academic choices for disabled college students prevail lower than 1% of the time, and that a number of of the almost two dozen listening to officers who difficulty rulings had by no means dominated in favor of a household.



The swimsuit claims the state’s practices violate the IDEA regulation, in addition to constitutional rights to due course of, and seeks a choice that forces modifications to Virginia’s insurance policies.

The Chalick’s son, who’s now 19, is profoundly disabled in accordance with the swimsuit, and was positioned in a particular training constructing in an FCPS college. After he struggled to make progress academically and behaviorally, his dad and mom sought his residential academic placement at a particular college in Winchester, in accordance with the lawsuit.

Nevertheless, FCPS rejected the dad and mom’ request. Later, the Chalick’s enchantment earlier than a listening to officer was additionally rejected.

The lawsuit claims the information it obtained by way of FOIA requests present, “Mother and father and disabled college students in Virginia nearly at all times lose, particularly in Northern Virginia.”

For instance, within the 11 years between 2010 and July 2021, there have been 395 circumstances introduced by dad and mom difficult a college’s resolution underneath the IDEA regulation. In simply three circumstances — lower than 1% of all circumstances — the listening to officer dominated in favor of the dad and mom who introduced the problem.

Statewide, over the identical time interval, there have been 847 circumstances introduced underneath the IDEA regulation and simply 13 rulings — 1.5% — in favor of fogeys, in accordance with the lawsuit.

The lawsuit stated research have proven that, nationally, dad and mom prevail in about 30% of circumstances introduced underneath the IDEA regulation.

The lawsuit claims the state’s division of training and native college techniques work collectively to keep up a “fastidiously curated” group of simply 22 listening to officers who take circumstances, and “who almost at all times rule in favor of college districts and towards dad and mom.”

Of the 22 listening to officers who issued rulings between 2010 and 2021, 14 of them by no means dominated absolutely in favor of a disabled scholar or household in a due course of listening to, in accordance with the lawsuit.

Whereas a major variety of circumstances filed by dad and mom by no means make it to a listening to and are withdrawn by dad and mom, the swimsuit says, “it’s doubtless that many dad and mom gave up, moderately than face important authorized payments, with little or no probability of success. Sadly, such parental deterrence is the meant consequence of Virginia’s fastidiously curated system of crony listening to officers.”

In a press release, Trevor Chalick stated the swimsuit goals to “shine a lightweight on and reveal the deeply troubling ruling document of Virginia listening to officers towards dad and mom of disabled youngsters in IDEA due course of circumstances. We consider it is a scandal that has existed for no less than twenty years.”

The Civil Proper Clinic of Georgetown Regulation College and regulation companies Susman Godfrey LLP and Merritt Regulation PLLC are all a part of the authorized group representing the Chalicks.

In an electronic mail, Charles Pyle, a VDOE spokesman, stated the division is conscious of the submitting however doesn’t touch upon pending litigation.

“The division is dedicated to making sure that college students with disabilities obtain all companies and helps that they’re entitled to underneath federal and state regulation,” Pyle stated.

WTOP has requested remark from FCPS.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.