Skip to content

Hospital Beats Incapacity Bias Swimsuit Over Intern’s Service Canine

Law360 (January 20, 2023, 6:55 PM EST) — A Michigan federal decide granted a win to a hospital in a nursing intern’s incapacity discrimination lawsuit, saying she could not show bias performed a job when the hospital revoked her service canine lodging.

US District Decide Paul D. Borman granted abstract judgment to Hurley Medical Middle on Thursday, placing an finish to College of Michigan-Flint pupil Mia Bennett’s swimsuit. She mentioned the hospital violated the People with Disabilities Act, the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and the Michigan Individuals with Disabilities Civil Rights Act when it mentioned she might now not convey her service canine to work after he prompted some hospital workers and sufferers to expertise extreme allergy reactions.

Bennett mentioned she wanted her Pembroke Welsh Corgi, Pistol, to observe her round to assist deal with her generalized nervousness dysfunction and the panic assaults that accompany it. Hurley argued that it took the suitable steps to have interaction within the ADA-mandated interactive course of with Bennett to accommodate her, however he mentioned he was compelled to rescind his invitation to Pistol after he started to pose a well being menace.

“No cheap jury might dispute that Hurley did conduct an individualized evaluation and fairly concluded that Pistol, who would have accompanied Bennett to each affected person on her rounds with medical doctors and nurses, was a direct menace to the well being and security of all of the sufferers and workers on [floors] 7E and 9E,” Decide Borman mentioned.

Although Bennett claimed that Hurley lower brief the interactive course of, Decide Borman was not satisfied that was the case as a result of he mentioned Hurley proposed a counter provide that might have allowed Bennett to convey Pistol to work however crate him whereas she was visiting sufferers. Bennett turned that possibility down, although, in accordance with the order.

Hurley additionally didn’t shut down Bennett’s proposal to get Pistol a “shed defender,” which is a onesie for a canine that incorporates shedding, however Bennett didn’t observe up on this concept after she realized there wasn’t one which match Pistol’s breed, the order mentioned.

As a result of Hurley advised Bennett in an electronic mail that it remained open to persevering with a dialog to finest accommodate her, Decide Borman concluded that the hospital didn’t act in unhealthy religion when it shut Pistol out of the premises.

Decide Borman additionally famous that the ADA provides a loophole for public entities to disclaim entry if a person poses a direct menace to the well being and security of others. He mentioned it was cheap for Hurley to conclude that Pistol posed a direct menace to folks’s security, particularly as a result of Pistol triggered an allergic response to 1 nurse that was so sturdy she needed to search medical consideration and miss two days of labor.

“Furthermore, Pistol’s disbursement of allergens was particularly harmful on 7E, as a result of a few of its sufferers are immunocompromised, and wanted to remain on that ground for his or her care,” Decide Borman mentioned. “Pistol’s allergens would have been equally harmful to the sufferers on 9E, which is an oncology medical unit.”

Plus, as a result of the hospital did not uncover the issues associated to the Pistol’s presence till after Bennett had already began her internship, it had restricted time to evaluate the scenario and got here up with an answer, Decide Borman mentioned.

Bennett filed her swimsuit towards Hurley in March 2021. She was a second-year undergraduate nursing pupil on the time and was required to finish sure rotations at educating hospitals akin to Hurley previous to commencement, in accordance with her grievance.

In keeping with Thursday’s order, Bennett was capable of end her rotation at Hurley with out Pistol and didn’t endure any panic assaults.

Nicholas Roumel, who represents Bennett, advised Law360 in a press release Friday that he is “very upset” however he is conferring with Bennett to determine subsequent steps.

Representatives for Hurley didn’t instantly reply to requests for remark.

Bennett is represented by Nicholas Roumel of NachtLaw PC.

Hurley Medical Middle is represented by Michael W. Edmunds of Gault Davison PC.

The case is Bennett v. Hurley Medical Middle, case quantity 2:21-cv-10471, within the US District Courtroom for the Jap District of Michigan.

–Modifying by Leah Bennett.

For a reprint of this text, please contact

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *