Skip to content

Jury awards $30 million in go well with towards California nursing dwelling

Sam Rios, who spent 30 years as director at Sacramento State's Chicano Studies program, is seen in 2001. A Sacramento jury has awarded $31 million in damages to Rios' family after they sued a Roseville nursing home over the 86-year-old's death.

Sam Rios, who spent 30 years as director at Sacramento State’s Chicano Research program, is seen in 2001. A Sacramento jury has awarded $31 million in damages to Rios’ household after they sued a Roseville nursing dwelling over the 86-year-old’s demise.

Sacramento Bee file

A Sacramento jury has returned verdicts totaling greater than $30 million towards the homeowners of a Roseville nursing dwelling after a distinguished retired Sac State professor died following a short keep on the dwelling.

The Superior Courtroom jury returned a verdict of $5.9 million in compensatory damages final week, and a $25 million verdict for punitive damages Tuesday after a lawsuit was filed towards the Pine Creek Care Heart and numerous company entities, veteran elder abuse legal professional Ed Dudensing mentioned.

The verdicts got here after a 79-day trial through which Dudensing argued that the nursing dwelling and its homeowners prioritized earnings over affected person care and reduce staffing till circumstances had been unsafe for residents comparable to Sam Rios Jr., an 86-year-old civil rights activist who spent two weeks at dwelling in 2017 and later died after creating strain ulcers on his heels.

“We hope and pray that each the nursing dwelling and the personal fairness industries will obtain the message despatched by the jury that it’s merely incorrect to prioritize earnings over affected person care,” Dudensing mentioned.

The Rios household sued Pine Creek and a variety of different company entities, together with proprietor Plum Healthcare Group, after Rios died from what Dudensing described as an agonizing demise at dwelling.

“The Plum group is actually probably the most profit-driven nursing dwelling chain I’ve ever encountered in my 20 years prosecuting elder abuse,” mentioned Dudensing, who gained a $42.5 million verdict in 2019 towards the Eskaton care middle in Orangevale, a verdict believed to be the most important of its variety in Sacramento on the time.

Pine Creek and Plum’s homeowners didn’t instantly reply to messages Tuesday.

Rios entered facility recovering from damaged hip

The Rios saga started with a easy fall at dwelling on April 11, 2017, that fractured Rios’ hip and led to him being handled at a Kaiser Permanente facility, then despatched to Pine Creek for short-term rehabilitation, court docket information say.

Upon admission at Pine Creek, Rios was famous to have redness on each heels and was recognized as “excessive danger” for breakdown of his pores and skin, court docket filings say.

“He arrived at Pine Creek with heel protectors that he had been sporting at Kaiser,” Dudensng’s trial temporary states. “Pine Creek workers put the heel protectors within the closet and by no means used any heel protectors on him.”

The nursing dwelling’s care plan for Rios didn’t doc the necessity to stop him from creating strain sores and he was re-positioned simply as soon as within the 42 shifts throughout which he was at Pine Creek, court docket filings say.

Dudensing instructed the jury in opening statements in November that Rios ought to have been re-positioned in mattress each two hours and each hour that he was seated in a chair.

“It isn’t tough, it isn’t rocket science,” Dudensing instructed the jury, which included three registered nurses.

Ulcers found two days later

Rios was discharged from Pine Creek on April 29, 2017, with out his heels being checked and with no instruction to the household on tips on how to stop strain sores on his heels, court docket information say.

On Might 1, when two dwelling well being nurses arrived to test on Rios they discovered “two huge strain ulcers on Mr. Rios’ heels,” court docket information say.

One of many heels had turned black, a improvement that “had not magically appeared throughout the 48 hours that Sam was at dwelling,” the trial temporary states.

“From Might 1, 2017 to the date of his demise on March 16, 2018, Sam Rios needed to reside with a painful to-the-bone proper heel strain sore, which stripped him of his means to stroll, share a mattress along with his spouse of forty years, and in the end considerably contributed to his demise,” the trial temporary says.

Rios was an Air Pressure veteran and former Sacramento State soccer participant who spent 30 years as director on the college’s Chicano Research program, incomes the nickname “El Profe” from his college students earlier than retiring in Might 2011, court docket information say.

Along with the punitive and compensatory damages, Dudensing mentioned attorneys charges are anticipated to whole between $4 million and $7 million.

State regulators had been instructed of neglect

Carole Herman, founder and president of Sacramento’s Basis Aiding the Aged, mentioned Tuesday that she had filed a grievance towards Pine Creek with the state Division of Public Well being over Rios’ therapy in 2018, alleging he had suffered quite a few falls, developed strain sores and was not cared for correctly.

She mentioned DPH “unsubstantiated” her grievance and that later appeals failed.

“To me, it is unlucky that the shoppers need to go to authorized motion to ensure that these amenities to be held accountable when DPH ought to have sanctioned this facility again in 2018 and they didn’t do it,” Herman mentioned. “The shoppers shouldn’t need to be submitting lawsuits towards the trade.

“The failure of DPH to carry these amenities accountable is why these individuals are suing.”

Sam Stanton has labored for The Bee since 1991 and has lined a wide range of points, together with politics, felony justice and breaking information.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *