Skip to content

Riders with Disabilities Sue MTA to Shut the Hole Between Subway Practice and Platform


The MTA is going through a brand new authorized problem from New Yorkers with disabilities — simply months after the transit company settled two different lawsuits that resulted in a dedication so as to add elevators or ramps at most subway stations by 2055.

Incapacity-rights advocate Sasha Blair-Goldensohn navigates a platform hole on the Columbus Circle subway station. | Ben Fractenberg/THE CITY

Three New Yorkers with disabilities on Tuesday filed a class-action lawsuit in Manhattan State Supreme Court docket that calls for the MTA repair the gaps between subway trains and station platforms that may problem riders who’re blind or use a wheelchair.

“A lot consideration is paid to offering stair-free entry within the subway system — and stair-fee entry is crucial, it is essential,” mentioned Christopher Schuyler, senior employees legal professional with the Incapacity Justice Program at New York Attorneys for the Public Curiosity. “Nevertheless it’s not the entire image.”

The go well with accuses the MTA of violating the town’s human rights regulation by not eliminating vertical and horizontal gaps of a number of inches and seeks to compel the company to search out fixes.

The courtroom papers cite how a number of transit techniques, together with these in Boston and Chicago, have carried out protections that may embrace units referred to as “bridge plates,” or retractable ramps which span the hole between platforms and trains.

In Hong Kong, the go well with says, staff present ramps to assist individuals with disabilities board trains and in addition name forward to stops the place a person might be exiting to make sure that employees have a ramp prepared there.

“We now have to sue to get them to be in compliance and that is unlucky for me,” plaintiff Jackie Goldenberg, 78, informed THE CITY. “It makes me really feel unloved by New York, fairly frankly.”

Visually impaired commuter Jackie Goldenberg is a plaintiff in a brand new class-action lawsuit towards the MTA. | Ben Fractenberg/THE CITY

The lawsuit comes after the MTA in June agreed to settle a pair of sophistication motion instances with accessibility advocates and laid out a timetable for equipping most stations with elevators or ramps inside many years.

It incorporates that sizable gaps between trains and platforms make it tough — and in some instances, not possible — for individuals in wheelchairs or with sight disabilities to board or exit trains.

The go well with says the MTA reportedly acknowledged as early as 2012 that the gaps ought to by no means exceed 2 inches vertically and 4 inches horizontally at platform sections designated accessible for wheelchair customers.

Quemuel Arroyo, the company’s chief accessibility officer, mentioned after Wednesday’s MTA board assembly, that the lawsuit “comes as a shock to all of us right here on the MTA” within the wake of the June settlement and different advances on accessibility.

“We’re actually shocked,” Arroyo mentioned. “I am a bit of disheartened that this got here again, however we’ll handle it within the courts.”

The criticism cites a 2013 report by the New York Metropolis Transit Riders Council that recognized 91 stations throughout a number of strains the place trains had extreme vertical and horizontal gaps.

They included a 6-inch vertical hole from southbound C trains on the fiftieth Road cease in Manhattan, a 6-inch horizontal hole between northbound B trains at 59th Road-Columbus Circle and 3-inch vertical gaps on southbound B trains at Dekalb Avenue in Brooklyn.

“I’m traumatized by the expertise of getting my wheelchair get caught as a result of extreme hole between the automobile and the platform,” mentioned one other plaintiff, Athena Savides, who repeatedly struggled to get her motorized wheelchair over a niche at 14th Road-Union Sq. . “That feeling of being trapped nonetheless offers me nervousness and retains me from utilizing the subway.”

A commuter enters an A prepare at Dyckman Road in Manhattan, Feb. 23, 2022. | Ben Fractenberg/THE CITY

Goldenberg, who has arthritis in her knees and describes herself as “a bit of frail” and with poor eyesight, mentioned her personal “daunting” worry of falling into the hole now retains her off the subway.

“I am taking cabs at this level or I am strolling,” she mentioned. “I can not afford to fall and that is what it actually comes all the way down to.”

As a part of its 2020-2024 capital plan — at greater than $50 billion, the most important in MTA historical past — the transit company agreed to place greater than $5 billion towards accessibility upgrades at 70 subway and Staten Island railway stations in a system the place simply over 1 / 4 of the 493 stops are at present in compliance with the Individuals with Disabilities Act.

“We have made an enormous dedication to [accessibility] and we will hold executing,” Janno Lieber, MTA Chairman and CEO, mentioned Wednesday.

The MTA accomplished 15 accessibility tasks throughout the pandemic and, with the Division of Metropolis Planning, additionally listed personal builders for assist with putting in elevators in stations that hyperlink to the builders’ neighboring properties.

Then got here the June 22 settlement, which Gov. Kathy Hochul, transit officers and accessibility advocates all hailed as historic for a system that is been sued repeatedly for accessibility points.

“The MTA is dedicated to keep up the identical degree of funding in ADA accessibility in not simply present, however future capital applications, till we obtain at the very least 95% of stations being accessible,” Lieber mentioned on the time of the settlement.

Goldenberg mentioned she’s hopeful the lawsuit will draw consideration to the obstacles confronted within the transit techniques by these with disabilities, together with having to “type of make a bit of hop” to board a prepare.

“I am far more conscious of it once I’m getting on,” she informed THE CITY. “It is not precisely the lengthy leap, but when the prepare is coming in and there’s a rush or a press to get in there, I may not all the time be capable to belief what I trusted 20 years in the past.”


THE CITY is an impartial, nonprofit information outlet devoted to hard-hitting reporting that serves the individuals of New York.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *