Skip to content

Tory MP Simon Clarke defiant over swipe at £35k nurses utilizing meals banks

Tory MP Simon Clarke voiced defiance as we speak regardless of being rebuked by Michael Gove for saying nurses pressured to make use of meals banks ought to ‘price range higher’.

The Leveling Up Secretary mentioned Mr Clarke – who held the identical put up in Liz Truss’s authorities – had despatched out the ‘unsuitable message’.

However Mr Clarke insisted that he ‘stands behind 100 per cent’ the remarks he made on a radio present yesterday as hundreds of nurses went out on strike in a bitter row over pay.

The Oxford-educated MP for Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland mentioned nurses incomes £35,000 shouldn’t be utilizing foodbanks and will as an alternative ‘take duty’ for their very own funds. He has been backed by some colleagues.

Nevertheless, Pat Cullen, basic secretary of the Royal School of Nursing (RCN), accused him of displaying ‘disdain’ for struggling staff.

‘To criticize anyone utilizing a foodbank is disgusting, heartlessly and dangerously out of contact,’ she mentioned.

In a spherical of interviews this morning, Mr Gove distanced himself from the feedback. Requested on BBC Breakfast if he agreed with Mr Clarke, Mr Gove mentioned: ‘I do not truly, no.

‘I do know what the person involved was making an attempt to say, I do know that he is a really good-hearted and generous-minded individual. However I feel within the phrasing the unsuitable message got here throughout.’

Nevertheless, Mr Clarke mentioned he stood by his phrases. ‘You’ll be able to have big respect for folks working in our public companies and likewise be clear that if you’re incomes £35,000, except there are very specific circumstances, you should not want to make use of a foodbank,’ he tweeted.

Leveling Up Secretary Michael Gove mentioned Simon Clarke – who held the identical put up in Liz Truss’s authorities – had despatched out the ‘unsuitable message’

Thousand of nurses are on strike in a bitter row over pay and working conditions - with some claiming they cannot afford to put food on the table

Thousand of nurses are on strike in a bitter row over pay and dealing situations – with some claiming they can not afford to place meals on the desk

Mr Clarke said nurses earning £35,000 who are using foodbanks should 'budget better'

Mr Clarke mentioned nurses incomes £35,000 who’re utilizing foodbanks ought to ‘price range higher’

Talking on Sky Information, Mr Gove mentioned: ”I’d by no means criticize nurses for one thing like that. I feel an important factor to do is to acknowledge that people who find themselves working within the NHS are individuals who have devoted their lives to a caring occupation.

‘I do know myself having seen the NHS shut up and private the devoted care that nurses and others who work within the NHS give.

‘In fact we need to do every little thing doable with the intention to be sure that persons are paid effectively and in accordance with their abilities…

‘However we additionally should stability that in opposition to the necessity to ensure public funds are spent correctly.’

Talking on BBC Radio Tees yesterday, Mr Clarke – who earns £84,000 as an MP – mentioned: ‘If you’re utilizing foodbanks and your common wage is £35,000 a 12 months then one thing is unsuitable together with your budgeting as a result of £35,000 shouldn’t be a wage on which you need to be counting on foodbanks.

‘I feel we simply have to be clear on this.

‘This debate has gotten out of hand, the common nurse’s wage is £35,000 and senior nurses earn as much as about £47,000.’

His remark echoed related remarks made by Tory colleague Brendan Clarke-Smith about firefighters final month.

The Bassetlaw MP triggered an offended backlash after posting on Twitter: ‘I respect the occupation, however £32,244 and utilizing a meals financial institution? By no means heard such a ridiculous factor in my life.’

One other Tory MP, Lee Anderson, lined up behind Mr Clarke as we speak, tweeting: ‘The purpose right here is that ANYONE (not simply nurses) incomes MORE than 30k and are utilizing foodbanks should have a budgeting downside.

‘I’ve constituents ie armed forces, bin males, bar workers, care staff, bus drivers, pensioners and many others. who can all stay on much less. Am I lacking one thing?’

Members of the RCN at the Florence Nightingale statue near the Florence Nightingale Community Hospital in Derby

Members of the RCN on the Florence Nightingale statue close to the Florence Nightingale Group Hospital in Derby

Ms Cullen mentioned the concern of nursing workers not with the ability to meet their payments was ‘palpable’, with ‘sky-high inflation’ leaving many ‘dwelling on a monetary knife-edge’.

‘When nurses are having to pay a whole bunch of kilos a month simply to get to work, cannot afford to place meals on the desk, and are pressured to chop again on shifts as a result of they can not afford ever-increasing childcare prices, one thing is severely unsuitable,’ Ms Cullen instructed the Mirror.

Trying to make clear his remarks to the BBC, the Tory MP later tweeted: ‘I used to be very clear that all of us admire the improbable work of our nurses. However if you’re incomes £35,000/12 months, with out very specific circumstances, you ought to not have to be utilizing a meals financial institution.’


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *